RRSP vs TFSA Calculator
Compare RRSP and TFSA side-by-side to find which registered account is better for your situation.
RRSP wins in your scenario(by $66,836.44)
Your current tax rate is higher than retirement rate, so deferring tax via RRSP is advantageous.
RRSP
Balance at Retirement
$607,604.00
After Withdrawal Tax
$473,931.12
Annual Tax Refund
$3,447.76
Annual RRSP Contribution
$10,447.76 = $7,000.00 + $3,447.76 refund
TFSA
Balance
$407,094.68
After Withdrawal (tax-free)
$407,094.68
Annual Tax Refund
$0
No impact on OAS/GIS
Withdrawals are invisible
How This Comparison Works
The two accounts are compared at the same out-of-pocket cost. Putting $7,000.00 a year into a TFSA costs $7,000.00. For an RRSP to cost the same, you contribute $10,447.76: at a 33% tax rate the deduction returns $3,447.76, so your net outlay is again $7,000.00. The RRSP grows on the larger amount, and every dollar that comes out of it is taxed at your retirement rate.
That leaves the result depending only on the two tax rates. Whatever the return or the number of years, the RRSP ends up at (1 − retirement rate) ÷ (1 − current rate) times the TFSA — here 78% ÷ 67% = 1.164. When the two rates are equal the accounts tie, and a lower rate in retirement is what makes the RRSP worth more. If you spend the refund instead of investing it, you are saving less in the RRSP than in the TFSA, and this comparison no longer applies.
Choose the retirement rate with care. RRSP and RRIF withdrawals count as income, so they can trigger the OAS recovery tax and reduce income-tested benefits such as the Guaranteed Income Supplement. TFSA withdrawals do neither. For a lower-income retiree who expects to receive GIS, the effective rate on RRSP income can be well above the bracket rate.
Frequently Asked Questions
When is RRSP better than TFSA?
When is TFSA better than RRSP?
Can I have both?
Official Data Sources
Related Calculators
People also use
Disclaimer: This calculator provides estimates based on publicly available data from CRA and other government sources. It does not constitute financial advice. Consult a qualified advisor for decisions about your specific situation.